As more plants opt for heat-resistant super alloys (HRSAs) -- stainless steel, Inconel, titanium and the like -- over aluminum, the chances of having the tool slip or pull out in its holder increases. But Big Kaiser's Jack Burley writes that his company's Mega Perfect Grip, a high performance milling chuck will not allow the tool to slip, and will do so without sacrificing accuracy.
The day a tool slips or pulls out in its holder during work on an aerospace part is a very bad day. I've gotten that call from plant managers and it's just not pleasant. As more companies opt for heat-resistant super alloys (HRSAs) -- stainless steel, iconel, titanium and the like -- over aluminum, the chances of these miscues are increasing.
The Mega Perfect Grip milling chucks combine the cutting performance of heavy duty milling chucks with the security against pullout of solid side lock tool holders.
These metals are a natural fit for aerospace builders. They are lightweight, yet strong and corrosive-resistant enough to achieve the requisite rigidity and durability for both engine and structural components with less material. These same properties, however, make them very, very difficult to machine. They require high cutting forces, generate extreme heat at the tool tip and the chips are difficult to break.
The tolerances tend to mirror what we see in automotive drivetrain parts of more common metals -- a few tenths of an inch difference between a good part and a scrap part -- but, the penalty for a scrap part is completely opposite. Some HRSA aerospace forgings cost anywhere from $20,000 to $40,000, and that's before the first cutting tool even starts work. What's more, with four, five even six sides often requiring cutting, these parts can take days to finish; starting over is a costly price to pay all its own.
The Mega Perfect Grip uses both the Weldon flat system and a high performance chuck. A special keeper key is positioned into the Weldon flat of the end mill. This unique lock mechanism prevents the slip and pullout of the tool during heavy cutting.
Tooling suppliers developed very aggressive end mills with high-helix, high-positive geometries that remove material through a sheering action in order to effectively cut these metals. Knuckle end mills even have added teeth-like geometries for even better grabbing of material. In fact, the geometries of cutters like these more and more resemble those of a screw.
Now, picture this: you're holding a bolt by the threads between your thumb and forefinger; with your other hand, you start turning the bolt; those threads will start moving out of your two fingers, no matter how hard you are squeezing it between your fingers. A milling cutter with a 35-degree helix angle interacting with a part isn't much different.
What's more, cutters wear quickly on these metals. Think about cutting a steak with a butter knife instead of a steak knife -- your hand has to work much harder. The same can be said about a holder with a dulling cutter. Sure, high-performance shrink fit, milling and collet chucks rely on friction and should't experience slippage or pullout, but combine tool wear with high sheer angles, cutting forces and axial stress and holders are pushed to extreme levels, making slippage or pullout very real possibilities.
Aerospace producers have always worked with the toughest of the toughest metals. Years ago, the National Aeronautics Society made an effort to lend a hand to its industry's metalworkers by helping to prevent pullout and its devastating results. Their solution was the Weldon flat, a mechanical side lock with a positive key in the holder that eliminates pullout.
For efficient removal of chips, high pressure and high volume jet-through coolant is a standard feature of the Mega Perfect Grip. The key grip grooves provide channels for high volume coolant to get to the cutter.
The style became the holder of choice for the industry and is still widely used today. Here's the rub: they were conceived well before both HRSAs became popular and milling tools were made with such complex geometries. As a result, shops will find that they are three to four times less efficient than the high-performance holders on HRSAs.
To sum up so far, we have high-performance holders that meet demanding tolerance requirements and extend cutter life, but run a slight risk of pullout or slippage as a cycle progresses. And we have the established side lock holder that won't allow the tool to slip, but can't match the efficiency or accuracy of its high performance counterpart. Both are reasonable choices, but still involve some risk.
Another holder type attempts to combine the best of both. Big Kaiser calls it the Mega Perfect Grip. It has both the Weldon flat system and a high performance chuck. The holder itself acts as a type of insurance, preventing days and tens of thousands of dollars in setbacks without sacrificing high accuracy.
A relatively new concept, this holder approach is understandably not yet widely adopted. Plant managers interested in this holder type more often say something along the lines of "I simply can't have a tool slip again," as opposed to, "I want prevent a tool from ever slipping" -- reactive, not proactive.
I've travelled the globe for more than two decades testing setups and tooling on exotic materials, trying to help shops solve their toughest problems. The unique properties and costs associated with scrap make the tests I've conducted on HRSAs among the toughest I've ever encountered.
It's up to each shop to do their own the risk/reward and cost/benefit analysis, but I'll tell you this, at the very least, become intimately familiar with how tools are wearing in these cuts. And select your holders carefully. Is investing in the right holder at the outset worth preventing that really, really bad day?
Want more information? Click below.